Government vs Corporations: The Battle of Security and Privacy

After Edward Snowden released information that the NSA was tapping into private companies servers and getting their information without their knowledge, corporations have made promises to customers and buffed up security on their servers immensely. Higher levels of encryption, no backdoors, and buffing up servers make it much harder for hackers to break into your sensitive information, but it also keeps the government out.

The United States is currently in or contemplating legal battles with large tech companies such as Apple, Google, and Microsoft to compel them to give them information, break encryptions, or leave them a way in to look at the data themselves. Specifically with Microsoft, the company refuses to hand over data to the government without an Irish warrant because the servers the data is stored in are in Dublin.  Companies aren’t willing to cooperate with the government on this because of the promises they made to their customers and the huge security breaches it could cause leaving possible holes for hackers to steal or tamper with data.

The UK is facing a similar issue where their MI5 is looking for more power from Parliament to keep up with technological advances, and Andrew Parker, Director General of MI5, recently said in an interview that companies have an ethical responsibility to to turn over the information the government wants to them.

Major corporations remain hesitant to readily give over information to the government for fear of backlash from consumers and the fact that the government has not really been truthful with them in the past.  This argument is definitely one that comes down to ethics and we must determine what point we sacrifice too much privacy for the sake of security.  We will have to see what the courts or Congress say on the matter.

Sources:

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/08/us/politics/apple-and-other-tech-companies-tangle-with-us-over-access-to-data.html?_r=0

http://www.scmagazine.com/andrew-parker-says-mi5-needs-greater-cyber-security-powers/article/439663/

– Quinn White

Advertisements